And the only cat I've known "not to like" belly rubs absolutely loves them, but he will also try to claw and bite the shit out of your hand while you do, which is why you use an oven mitt while giving them.
Like, he will literally try to bring you that oven mitt and roll over for you in anticipation.
Or maybe he just likes murder.
If they are my cats, choose the dark one because the white doesn't want to play, he just wants food, and will literally do this if I try.