this post was submitted on 01 Dec 2025
310 points (98.4% liked)
RPGMemes
14409 readers
400 users here now
Humor, jokes, memes about TTRPGs
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Yep. Feel like we just had some posts about this. People who write that kind of backstory should just write a book. It's especially bad in games like D&D where you're starting out as a level 1 nobody. Some games, even some games of D&D, start at higher power levels, so the story is at least mechanically plausible.
I believe Brian Murphy said you can write that backstory for a D&D character and make it work if it's a comedy and all of that greatness is just in your character's head. I don't get to play much but tried to take a similar mindset: my character isn't as badass as they think they are.
I joined a running campaign (still at the low levels) set in a magic library and I had a character with a comically egregious case of that kind of back story. The campaign had a tight foundation with everyone else already knowing each other and being there for a reason.
It wasn't easy to recon me in, so we didn't and I worked this out with the DM. I just had all these things I'd reference. Grand, level-inapproriate adventures, offering impossible feats as part of insane plans, being a key figure in historical events that the others were quite sure had never happened, etc. But absolutely no other sign of insanity or chronic lying in my serious, good-aligned, heroic character.
The DM let everyone have fun scratching their heads over it for a few sessions before they stumbled on my character's series and found out he was just a fictional hero spawned by the library to assist their quest. His level was from the creation magic and had nothing to do with his real-only-to-him backstory.
It worked out in that very very specific setting.
Ok, that's brilliant and awesome. Brisome.